Who won American Idol season 23? Carrie Underwood blasted for her reaction as winner is crowned

The highly-anticipated finale of season 23 of ABC’s American Idol, which aired on May 18, 2025, was a thrilling event that culminated in a significant moment for fans and contestants alike. After an exciting season filled with incredible talent, Jamal Roberts, a 27-year-old elementary school teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, won the coveted title of American Idol, defeating runner-up John Foster in a nail-biting conclusion that left viewers captivated.

Finale Highlights

The three-hour finale delivered unforgettable performances from the top three finalists, Jamal, Breanna Nix, and John, with Breanna being the first to exit the competition during the event. This season finale was a showcase of talent, featuring guest appearances by renowned artists such as Jelly Roll, Jessica Simpson, Salt-N-Pepa, Goo Goo Dolls, Josh Groban, and Patti LaBelle.

In an unprecedented turnout, a staggering 26 million votes were cast during the finale, marking this as the most significant viewer engagement in the history of the show. The enthusiasm of fans was palpable, and it ultimately pushed Jamal to victory, making his dream of becoming an American Idol a reality.

Controversy Surrounding Carrie Underwood

Carrie Underwood. Serving as a judge for the first time this season, Carrie faced considerable backlash for her perceived lack of enthusiasm during Jamal’s final performance. While her fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan stood in applause, Carrie remained seated, which did not go unnoticed by the audience. Many interpreted her demeanor as a sign of discontent with Jamal’s crowning as the winner. This sparked a wave of criticism on social media, with many fans calling for her removal from the judging panel for the upcoming season.

Underwood’s Reflection and Performance

In light of the controversy, Underwood took a moment to reflect on her emotional journey throughout the season. As she celebrated 20 years since her own win in Season 4, Carrie performed her heartfelt song “I’m Gonna Love You” alongside Slater Nalley, featuring her original collaborator Cody Johnson. Additionally, she participated in a collaborative performance of “Stuck On You” by Lionel Richie with her fellow judges, showcasing her impressive vocal abilities while adding to the emotional depth of the finale.

The contrasting reactions from judges illustrated the often-tense dynamics within reality television, garnering attention and sparking discussions among viewers. While some fans were quick to defend Underwood, asserting that her personal connection to the show may have influenced her response, others were adamant in their disapproval.

Expectations for Season 24

As fans looked ahead to what season 24 has in store, speculation about Underwood’s return to the judging panel began to circulate. While her participation has not yet been confirmed, many believe that the outpouring of public interest and dialogue surrounding her role this season ensures that she will be back to guide the hopeful contestants again. The anticipation for the next season is already building, and fans are eager to see how the dynamics between the judges evolve and how new talent will emerge.

Overall, the finale of American Idol season 23 was a celebration of extraordinary talent, creativity, and emotional storytelling—a hallmark of what makes the series so captivating. The discussions and reactions from fans only underscore the passion that surrounds this beloved competition.

To stay updated on the latest news and developments regarding American Idol and its upcoming season, be sure to follow along and join the conversation. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a new viewer, the excitement for the next season promises to bring even more memorable moments.

Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
Source: New York Post